Advertisement
The platform behind our analysis
Charts, the WPI relative-strength map, seasonality, fundamentals, dark pool and GEX: the tools we use to write The Financial Spectator’s reports.
ChartsWPISeasonalityFundamentalsDark poolGEX
Enter DOMINA ›The free area opens without registration
DOMINA: chart with GEX gamma walls and dark pool bubbles, WPI, seasonality and fundamentals
GEXDark poolChartWPISeasonalityFundamentals
Markets

October Turns the Rankings Upside Down

Investments

Buffett stays ahead in 2026, but All Weather wins the month. Three portfolio models, three different exposures and one question: where was return truly generated?

  • Portfolio Monitor
  • Asset Allocation
  • All Weather
  • 60/40 Portfolio
  • Treasuries
AudienceINVEST
Copertina Ottobre ribalta la classifica con riferimento al confronto tra i portafogli Warren Buffett, Ray Dalio All Weather e 60/40
The Financial Spectator · editorial analysis

The comparison examines three passive strategies that approach the relationship between growth and capital preservation in different ways. The percentages shown are the reference weights of their respective allocations: these may shift over the course of the year as prices move, while the rebalancing provided for in the simulation takes place at the beginning of January.

01. Three ways to build a portfolio

Warren Buffett Portfolio

The Warren Buffett Portfolio follows a predominantly equity-oriented approach, with 90% invested in large US companies via the VV ETF and the remaining 10% in short-term Treasuries through SHY. The objective is to participate broadly in equity market growth, assigning the fixed-income component a limited stabilising role. This structure tends to benefit from phases that are favourable to equities, but is more exposed to market corrections. The risk classification is very high.

Ray Dalio All Weather

The All Weather model is designed to spread exposure across assets capable of responding to different economic conditions. It comprises 30% equities, 55% Treasuries across intermediate and long maturities, and 15% split between gold and commodities. Diversification helps to offset certain adverse movements, but the high weighting in bonds — particularly long-duration — makes the portfolio sensitive to interest rate fluctuations. Its risk profile is classified as medium.

Stocks/Bonds 60/40 Portfolio

The 60/40 represents the classic balance between market participation and fixed-income exposure. It allocates 60% to US equities through VTI, which covers a broader universe than large-cap stocks alone, and 40% to US bonds via BND. Relative to Buffett, it reduces equity exposure; relative to All Weather, it maintains a simpler construction, with no dedicated allocation to gold or commodities. It serves as a useful benchmark for assessing the contribution of bonds during periods of volatility, while offering no guarantee of protection when equities and bonds decline simultaneously. The risk profile is high.

02. October under review

The October snapshot places All Weather in first position with a return of 2.02%, followed by the 60/40 at +0.41%; Buffett retreats 0.90%. Looking at the year-to-date picture, the order reverses: the 90/10 leads with a gain of 10.47%, ahead of the 60/40 at 6.90% and All Weather at 5.31%.

Chart 1 — October returns, YTD returns and YTD drawdowns for the three portfolios
Barre dei rendimenti di ottobre 2026 di All Weather (+2,02%), 60/40 (+0,41%) e Buffett 90/10 (−0,90%), con tabella di rendimento YTD e drawdown massimo YTD
Source: LazyPortfolioETF; analysis by The Financial Spectator.

03. Where performance comes from

Long-dated Treasuries shift the outcome

The decisive contribution to All Weather comes from the fixed-income sleeve. In October, the TLT ETF, which tracks Treasuries with maturities of more than twenty years, gained 5.64%, while IEI, exposed to the three-to-seven-year segment, rose 2.00%. The combined weighting of the two instruments reaches 55% of the model — sufficient to support the portfolio, even in the presence of other negative components.

In contrast, GLD fell 6.58%. Gold accounts for just 7.5% of the allocation, and its decline was partially offset by a +3.99% gain in DBC, the diversified commodities basket. October's result therefore stems from genuine cross-asset compensation, rather than a broad-based rally across all portfolio holdings.

Chart 2 — Monthly change of the eight underlying ETFs in October 2026
Barre orizzontali delle variazioni di ottobre 2026 di VV, SHY, VTI, BND, TLT, IEI, DBC e GLD, da −6,58% dell'oro a +5,64% dei Treasury oltre 20 anni
Source: LazyPortfolioETF; analysis by The Financial Spectator.

The 60/40 benefits from the bond recovery

In the balanced benchmark, VTI retreats 0.71% while BND gains 2.37%. The fixed income allocation thereby cushions the impact of the equity component, allowing the portfolio to close the month in positive territory. This mechanism works when bond returns and equity returns move in opposite directions; it loses part of its effectiveness when the two asset classes decline in tandem.

Buffett retains the annual lead, with a different risk profile

The 90/10 structure leaves little room for offsetting moves. VV gives up 1.08%, while SHY gains 0.92%, but the limited weight of short-dated Treasuries is insufficient to reverse the month's sign. The YTD picture remains favourable because equities have contributed more substantially to the gains accumulated since the start of the year. Greater participation in rallies entails, symmetrically, greater vulnerability during corrections.

The session of 30 October illustrated how uneven the market can be: the decline in large-cap technology stocks penalised capitalisation-weighted indices, while a broader segment of the market held up better. For a portfolio that is almost entirely invested in equities, this distinction matters, as the weight of the largest companies directly influences the ETF's performance.

04. The Test of Time: Return, Risk and Recovery

Long-term statistics shift the basis for assessment. Over ten years, Buffett posts the highest annualised return at 14.12%, followed by the 60/40 at 9.61% and All Weather at 5.94%. The advantage is accompanied, however, by higher volatility and a greater potential depth of losses. Comparing returns alone would omit this part of the story.

The four tables use the same definitions and a common reference date of 31 October 2026. The Sharpe and Sortino ratios measure return relative to risk, with the latter focused on adverse movements; the Ulcer Index summarises how deep and persistent drawdowns have been. The recovery time, expressed in months, indicates how long it has historically taken to return from a prior peak to a new high.

Chart 3 — Risk and Return Metrics at 1, 5, 10 and 20 Years
Quattro tabelle con rendimento, deviazione standard, Sharpe, Sortino, Ulcer Index, drawdown massimo e mesi di recupero dei tre portafogli su 1, 5, 10 e 20 anni
Source: LazyPortfolioETF; analysis by The Financial Spectator.

05. Operational Ranking

There is no single winner, as rankings vary depending on what is being measured. The month rewards the model most favoured by duration; the year rewards the model with the greatest equity exposure; the drawdown history provides a different reading of the robustness of the journey.

Chart 4 — Ranking: best in October, best YTD and lowest twenty-year drawdown
Tre schede: All Weather migliore di ottobre con +2,02%, Buffett migliore YTD con +10,47%, All Weather con il drawdown a 20 anni più contenuto pari a −20,58%
Source: LazyPortfolioETF; analysis by The Financial Spectator.

06. The Author's Analysis

October: Risk Becomes Selective

The month unfolded against a backdrop of mixed macroeconomic signals. In the United States, the jobs report released on 2 October showed just 29,000 new payrolls and an unemployment rate of 4,2%; the September CPI, published on 14 October, recorded annual inflation at 3,7%. The PCE, an indicator closely monitored by the Fed, also remained elevated at 3,6%. In the face of this combination, on 28 October the central bank kept rates unchanged at 3,75–4,00%, without dispelling uncertainty over future moves.6, 7, 8, 9

The risk appetite thus became more selective, particularly in the latter part of the month. The quarterly results from Alphabet and Amazon reignited concerns about the cost of artificial intelligence investment and its ability to generate cash; the weakness of large-cap technology stocks weighed on indices, while Treasuries attracted defensive buying.10, 11 At the same time, tensions in the Middle East and attacks on Saudi energy infrastructure supported oil prices and the risk premium on commodities. This backdrop explains why October rewarded the fixed income component of both All Weather and 60/40, without triggering a uniform flight from all risk assets.12

Year-to-date: why Buffett remains ahead

Broadening the perspective to 2026, a different story emerges. Through September, the major global equity indices had gained more than 12%, despite rising government yields, sharply higher oil prices and ongoing wars. Earnings growth and AI-related investment had continued to underpin appetite for equities, while rate pressure had complicated the task of allocations with greater duration exposure.13

It is in this context that the Buffett 90/10 built its annual advantage. The 60/40 participated in the rally with greater moderation, while All Weather had to contend with a fixed income sleeve far more sensitive to interest rates. October corrected this hierarchy on a monthly basis only: the recovery in Treasuries favoured Dalio, but did not erase the equity returns accumulated over the preceding ten months. The comparison confirms that diversification can alter the path of returns without guaranteeing leadership at every stage.

November: what could change

To assess whether October's move may continue, I would focus above all on employment, inflation and technology earnings. Fresh signs of a slowdown in the labour market, accompanied by less acute price pressures, could provide further support for Treasuries; persistent inflation, partly driven by energy, would risk reigniting upward pressure on yields and penalising portfolios with heavier bond allocations. Quarterly results, starting with NVIDIA on 17 November, will reveal how willing the market remains to reward AI-driven growth.14

The geopolitical front also remains open: an easing of tensions in the Middle East or concrete steps in Ukraine peace negotiations could reduce the energy risk premium, while fresh escalation would make it harder for inflation to recede. The Fed's next meeting is scheduled for 8–9 December. For now the most significant observation is the divergence between the month and the year: Buffett leads on cumulative performance, Dalio has benefited from the return of duration demand, and the 60/40 has preserved its intermediate role. A single monthly rotation is not yet sufficient to speak of a durable regime change.15

Upcoming events

  • 6 November US Employment (NFP)
  • 10 November US CPI Inflation
  • 17 November NVIDIA Earnings
  • 18 November Fed October Minutes
  • 8–9 December Next FOMC

Calendar as known on 2 November 2026; geopolitical events have no predictable dates.

07. Sources and methodology

Nominal series in USD, updated to 31 October 2026. Portfolio simulations assume zero transaction costs and taxes, reinvested dividends and annual rebalancing on 1 January. Long-term data are in part reconstructed using equivalent historical series predating the launch of ETFs: they do not represent a genuinely investable performance across the full historical horizon. Risk metrics are calculated on a monthly frequency. Returns in excess of one year are annualised; 'Start to Recovery' refers to the maximum drawdown of the respective horizon, and asterisks in the original indicate recoveries still in progress.

The YTD Max Drawdown uses the maximum intra-year trough of the 2026 nominal series, which differs from the current drawdown. Movements in individual components represent ETF returns and not an exact accounting attribution of portfolio results. Risk classification follows the source for each model. The Observatory is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an investment recommendation.

Sources

  1. LazyPortfolioETF, Warren Buffett Portfolio: composition, performance, metrics and drawdown.
  2. LazyPortfolioETF, Ray Dalio All Weather: composition, performance, metrics and components.
  3. LazyPortfolioETF, Stocks/Bonds 60/40: composition, performance, metrics and drawdown.
  4. Associated Press, Context on the month-end equity session (2026-10-30).
  5. MarketWatch, Market breadth and differences between market cap-weighted and equal-weight indices (2026-10-31).
  6. BLS, US September employment: +254,000 new jobs and unemployment rate at 4.1% (2026-10-02).
  7. BLS, September Consumer Price Index: +3.7% year-on-year (2026-10-14).
  8. BEA, September PCE at 3.6% year-on-year (2026-10-29).
  9. Federal Reserve, FOMC decision and monetary policy communications (2026-10-28).
  10. Reuters, Alphabet, quarterly earnings and sell-off in AI stocks (2026-10-29).
  11. Reuters, Tech weakness, Treasuries and month-end dynamics (2026-10-30).
  12. Reuters, Middle East tensions, oil and the war in Ukraine (2026-10-22).
  13. Reuters, Year-to-date performance of equities, Treasuries and oil (2026-09-30).
  14. NVIDIA Investor Relations, Quarterly results scheduled for 17 November (2026-10-28).
  15. Federal Reserve, 2026 calendar: next FOMC on 8–9 December, October minutes and scheduled communications.
This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice or a solicitation to invest. Analyses, estimates and scenarios reflect information available as of the publication date and are subject to change.
This article was produced with the support of artificial intelligence.
📡 Follow the Trading Room live sessions
Analyses come to life in real time on our Telegram channel, from which Trading Room sessions are launched.
Join the Telegram channel →
Newsletter

Don’t miss the next analysis

Subscribe to our free newsletter and get it at the start of every week.